Please reconsider your decision on voting buttons
The voting buttons are an ever-present aspect of a bunch of sites' graphical identity, and they pull a disproportionate amount of weight in making the theming feel like a complete skin rather than just some surface-level attributes. My main site has fairly bland voting arrows and they're really a joy to see in the sites that do have them.
It would be a real shame if these were lost:
Image may be NSFW.
Clik here to view.
Status: as per the follow-up thread, this is currently status-going-away, and indeed
things like voting and favorite buttons are a core part of the Q&A experience that should be shared across the network. It was a mistake that we ever allowed for those to be themed.
so, you know... =(. I rather disagree with the "should be shared" aspect - instead, I see "site that has gorgeous voting buttons" as a strong indicator that I'm on a Stack Exchange site (with the associations that has regarding the quality of the content). But it appears that SE places less value on those aspects. Oh well.